What role should prisons have in our justice system?

An extract from the 2023-2024 HM Chief Inspector of Prisons for England and Wales:

“With many prisons severely overcrowded and understaffed, inspectors found men and women continued to spend far too long locked in their cells with nothing to do thanks to the woeful provision of education, training or work. Out of the 32 closed prisons the report covers, 30 were rated poor or insufficiently good in our assessment for purposeful activity. Rather than prisoners participating in activities or interventions to reduce their risk of reoffending and support their mental and physical health during their time behind bars, inspectors found a surge in illicit drug use, self-harm and violence.”
https://hmiprisons.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmipris_reports/annual-report/

Prisons have been a cornerstone of criminal justice systems for millennia, with evidence of their use dating back to 600 BC. In the UK, institutions like Newgate Prison have histories stretching back centuries. Today, prisons remain a central yet controversial element of our approach to crime and punishment.

At the heart of the debate lies the fundamental purpose of prisons: are they primarily for punishment or rehabilitation? Many argue that prisons should focus on reforming offenders, providing education, vocational training, and psychological support to prepare inmates for successful reintegration into society. Others contend that the punitive aspect of incarceration is crucial for justice and deterrence. In the UK, for instance, the Ministry of Justice states that prisons should serve multiple purposes: punishing offenders, protecting the public, and aiding rehabilitation.

The effectiveness of prisons in reducing crime and ensuring public safety is another contentious issue globally. While incarceration does physically separate offenders from society, questions remain about its long-term impact on crime rates and recidivism. In many countries, reoffending rates remain high (25.5% overall in the UK, rising to 55.5% for adults released from custodial sentences of less than 12 months) Notably the difference for men and women is around 6 percentage points.

Critics argue that prison environments often exacerbate criminal behaviour, creating a cycle of reoffending rather than breaking it. Moreover, the societal costs of maintaining large prison populations are significant, both financially and socially. Mass incarceration has led to overcrowding, strain on public resources, and profound effects on communities, particularly minority groups who are often disproportionately represented in prison populations.

These challenges have led to increased interest in alternative forms of justice and rehabilitation. Restorative justice programs, community service, electronic monitoring, and drug treatment courts are among the options being explored and implemented in various jurisdictions. These alternatives aim to address the root causes of criminal behaviour while maintaining public safety and reducing the reliance on traditional incarceration.

As we grapple with these complex issues, several questions emerge:

• How can societies balance the need for public safety with the goal of offender rehabilitation?
• Are there circumstances where alternatives to prison could be more effective in reducing crime and recidivism?
• What do current prison systems reveal about a society's values and priorities?
• How might approaches to criminal justice evolve in the coming decades, and what role will prisons play in that future?
• What if we didn’t have prisons?

For further reading:
"World Prison Brief" by the Institute for Crime & Justice Policy Research: https://www.prisonstudies.org/

"The Prison System in England and Wales" by the House of Commons Library:
https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8161/

Hope, legitimacy and carceral citizenship: using walking methodologies to understand peoples’ experience of probation supervision
https://howardleague.org/current-research-2/hope-legitimacy-and-carceral-citizenship-using-walking-methodologies-to-understand-peoples-experience-of-probation-supervision/

Reducing Reoffending: The 'What Works' Debate
https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/RP12-71/RP12-71.pdf

Please support the pub by purchasing a beverage.