What weāre about
P&G is more than just a group of people. It is a community. A community of philosophers, thinkers, book readers, paper readers, and folks that ask the foundational questions. What is the meaning of life? How do we know what we know? What makes us human? These are some of the questions that P&G members explore together through lively discussions and debates. But P&G is not only about intellectual pursuits. It is also a community of thoughtful people coming together to hike, and hangout. Whether it's enjoying the beauty of nature, sharing a meal, or playing games, P&G members bond over their common interests and values. P&G is a community where you can find friends who challenge you to grow and support you along the way.
Upcoming events (4+)
See all- Religion: Freedom of, and Freedom from.Link visible for attendees
ATHEIST SOCIETY - Melbourne, Australia.
Some of us are participating in their online event.
Leslie Allan (Rational Realm) will present the topic and lead the discussion.
The ZOOM link will appear for those who RSVP.
Meeting ID: 849 0598 8227 - - Passcode: 428111The Atheist Society welcomes ALL viewpoints, including criticism of Atheism.
Enquiries: [email protected]
Facebook and Website for past and future Atheist Society topics, etc.
This event is hosted on the Meetup Zoom platform of the Existentialist Society.
- Alvin I. Goldman and Erik J. Olsson | Reliabilism and the Value of KnowledgeLink visible for attendees
Reading is sent via Email instantly: By simply adding your email to our form, you'll be subscribed to P&G's weekly philosophy reading materials. You can expect to receive next week 's read on Tuesday PTS-time, with the reading materials sent via email immediately after you enter your email.
https://forms.gle/biYrDyLPa8xZHvo96The Readings we have done so far and other past meetings:
https://opaque-artichoke-859.notion.site/Phil-Gamblers-Events-Reading-List-a8ec151f63c045808c5faa4f25aeb554?pvs=4Our Discord Group:
https://discord.gg/Ee6FwrNmjaAlvin Goldman's paper, "Reliabilism and the Value of Knowledge," explores the idea that knowledge is more valuable than mere true belief. Here's a brief summary:
Goldman argues that reliabilism, which states that a belief counts as knowledge if it is produced by a reliable process, faces a challenge known as the swamping problem. This problem suggests that if a true belief is valuable, then adding reliability to it doesn't make it any more valuable3. In other words, once a belief is true, its method of acquisition doesn't add extra value.
Goldman proposes two solutions to this problem:- Conditional Probability Solution: Knowledge is more valuable because it is a better indicator of future true beliefs.
- Independent Value Solution: Reliable processes can bring independent value, making knowledge more valuable than mere true belief.
In essence, Goldman is trying to show that knowledge, as defined by reliabilism, has additional value beyond just being true.
