In this episode, Dr. Nash Jocic will explore one of Friedrich Nietzsche’s most controversial, provocative, and intriguing philosophical ideas: that life can only be justified as an aesthetic phenomenon. Though this claim is brief and direct, it carries profound complexity. Why, for Nietzsche, would life even require justification? Was life in need of justification to begin with? Had life not already been justified up to that point? Didn’t religions, like Christianity, provide a justification for life? And what about Schopenhauer’s views?
To support his claim, Nietzsche introduces the Greek gods Apollo and Dionysus, portraying them as central figures in what he considers the pinnacle of art—Attic tragedy. Used metaphorically as opposing forces within human nature—reason and passion—these deities, though contrasting, are shown to be essential to one another.
Nietzsche suggests that only their fusion through the medium of tragedy creates a foundation for justifying life. However, this understanding of tragedy is not accessible to all; only those with "nobly formed natures" who experience suffering more deeply than others can justify life through tragedy. Others, Nietzsche implies, may end up understanding tragedy as the best proof that life is not worth living, as Schopenhauer has thought.
Once again, I kindly ask all participants to purchase food and drinks from the bar, as this is our way of showing gratitude to the management for allowing us to use their space. Thank you.
